All breakdowns

Can a Piece of Junk Mail Fill a Restaurant?

Howdy, creeps…

As promised yesterday, I am going to spitball today about how I might, if I were to be hired by Mr. Fuji, help him put butts in chairs at his restaurant.

There are a million different ways one could tackle this problem…

You've got all the social media stuff these days (Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, blah blah blah)… You can do organic or paid, or both, on all of these platforms.

Could also do paid local search with Google. Like if I were sitting in my truck at 11am on a Tuesday and got a hankering for some hibachi and entered "hibachi near me" into my phone's browser, I could make sure that Mr. Fuji's ad was served up.

You also have paid advertising in local Valpak mailers or newspapers.

Or, I could submit a super cool story to the local news about how Fuji came into existence, highlight all the wonderful things about it, and hope that one of them thought it was cool enough to bring on Mr. Fuji for a little 5-minute segment.

Or, there is EDDM (Every Door Direct Mail).

Without knowing anything whatsoever about Fuji's economics, including whether or not they even want or need advertising, this is purely guesswork.

But, this also gives me free rein to make up whatever story I want.

So, the story I am making up is that Mr. Fuji came to me and said, "Hey Kurt, I read some of the stuff on your site and it seems like you might be able to help me out.

We currently have a problem. The problem is that on weekdays, we are only about half-capacity at lunchtime. On weekends, we're slammed busy. But weekdays we're not. I'd like to always be busy. What can you do?"

After some back and forth, we get to the meat of things.

I ask him how much he's willing to spend in order to get to the point of being packed on weekdays at lunchtime.

I also ask him what he would need to see in the first month in order to feel confident that my idea is working and make him comfortable continuing on with me.

We get to the point where he's willing to test things out by spending $4k in month one. If I am able to measurably bring in $2k worth of new customers (ones who would not have come in had they not been exposed to my advertising), he would be willing to continue on to the next month.

Not a huge budget, and not a huge return. But that's how initial campaign attempts go. If I'm able to return half of his ad spend in month one, I'm on to something. It will be another month or two to break even, and then onward from there.

Obviously, the ultimate goal (of any advertising endeavor) is to spend $1 and bring back more than $1. Once you figure out how to do that, then it would be silly not to throw as much money as you have available at the campaign.

And so, now it comes down to what exactly to do. What to try first.

Welp, I am not an expert at any of these methods. There is probably an expert out there from each field (Meta ads expert, Instagram expert, LinkedIn expert, Google search expert, newspaper expert, Valpak expert, etc., etc.) who could put together an awesome attempt at any of their various things.

But Mr. Fuji came to me, not them. So he's stuck with my proposition.

And my proposition is…….. Direct mail.

There is so much digital loudness and noise out there these days….

I'm sure a video could be made to work on Instagram that is served to the right people and gets Fuji to fill up on weekdays. Same with Meta ads. Someone could put together the right combination of words, images, and video that captures enough interest at a low enough cost that Fuji might fill up on weekdays.

But that ain't my bag today. Today, my bag is direct mail.

What sort of words, images, and/or offers could I put on a piece of paper that might cause some sleepy weirdo, who is yawning as he opens his mailbox, to say, "Honey, look at this… Have you ever heard of Fuji Buffet? That food looks great. And look at this deal… Maybe we ought to try lunch there this week."

Certainly there is something I can have printed that would entice folks to give Fuji a try, no?

So, what will I send? What will it say? Will it be a normal-sized postcard? Or a jumbo oversized postcard? Or a personal-looking envelope with a handwritten letter? Or a big manila envelope with some sort of lumpy object inside?

Hmmmm….

My gears are really going right now.

What about a fortune cookie that has some sort of discount on it for coming in?

Nah, that thing will get smashed in the mail.

What about a handwritten note that says something like:

"Hey there. I'm Mr. Fuji. I own Fuji Buffet. Have you ever heard of it? It's a Japanese buffet and hibachi joint on 28th St.

Are you one of the folks who automatically thinks 'ewww' when you hear oriental buffet? If so, I get it. A lot of them are, in fact, pretty gross.

But not my buffet. No, sir.

We keep 7 staff members on hand at all times to make sure every buffet station is sanitized and clean. They literally have no other job. They also make sure the food is always full and fresh.

7 people with one full-time job: Make sure this place is squeaky clean.

I'm the only buffet in town that can say that.

We also have the best food (by a long shot) of any of my competitors. It truly isn't even close.

In fact, since you can't really take my word for it, why don't you come in sometime next week from 11am–2pm for lunch? If it's not the best Japanese buffet you've ever experienced, I'll make your meal free of charge.

I'm serious. Take this letter with you. If you get done and think to yourself, 'Hmmm, I think Dragon Fry over on Eastern and Broadway is better,' I will let you walk out without paying.

That's how confident I am you're gonna love my restaurant."

….

Or something like that.

Man, there are so many angles a handwritten, personalized-looking letter could take.

And how cool would that be to get? When is the last time you got a promotional piece of mail from a local business that did not look like some news-blast postcard thing?

Ya know what, I'm out of time right now….

I need to go get my CNC running, but my brain is flowing with so many ideas that I'm gonna write a few more options of letters (from Mr. Fuji) to the general public. In fact, I'm going to make tomorrow's post more of the same.

More personal letters to the public about Fuji, from Mr. Fuji himself.

When I'm done, maybe I'll have you all respond and tell me which one you feel would land the best. Or maybe you'll think they all suck. That's fine too.

What's Mr. Fuji gonna do, fire me?

C-ya tomorrow.